Follow Slashdot blog updates by subscribing to our blog RSS feed

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×
EU Android Google IT Technology

Bing Loses Out To DuckDuckGo in Google's New Android Search Engine Ballot (theverge.com) 37

Google announced last week the alternative search engines it will show to new Android users in the EU, with DuckDuckGo the most frequently offered choice and Bing tied for last place. From a report: EU citizens setting up Android devices from March 1 will given a choice of four search engines to use as their default, including Google. Whichever provider they chose will become the default for searches made in Chrome and through Android's home screen search box. A dedicated app for that provider will also be installed on their device.
This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

Bing Loses Out To DuckDuckGo in Google's New Android Search Engine Ballot

Comments Filter:
  • Compare their search results. It's pretty clear that behind the scenes, DuckDuckGo is querying Bing's search engine and returning their results. I'm guessing the draw is not the quality of the results but whether the user is being tracked.
    • by DNS-and-BIND ( 461968 ) on Monday January 13, 2020 @04:54PM (#59617388) Homepage
      And having used them for a white (I know, horrors) Bing isn't that bad. I say this as a lifelong Microsoft hater. I have the official membership badge and hat. But not only is Bing not that bad, it also has a really good video search for porn, and it lacks the "curated" search results. By which I mean censored, because Google can and does penalize sources that don't agree with it to page 137 of results, and elevate sources that agree with it, to the point of them coming up very high on the first page on search results that match the politics of Google. It's a wonderful relief not being subject to that.
      • But not only is Bing not that bad, it also has a really good video search for porn

        SOLD!

      • by rtb61 ( 674572 )

        Why 'hate' M$, they are a shite abusive company and should not be trusted, hate does not come into it. Just avoid them as much as possible, they are unreliable, not to be trusted, privacy invasive and getting worse. Although Google has managed to overtake them in the evil stakes, that does not make M$ any better.

        Right for now, well, promote https://duckduckgo.com/?q=duck... [duckduckgo.com] where you go. Let's try to push it past Google "do all the evil you can legally get away with" (corrupt democracy to favour your corpo

      • Ehh just checked, and DDG is definitely returning unique search results.
        • All search engines return results based on what they know about you, ie. they aren't unbiased.

          If you're comparing a direct Bing search with a DDG search then you can get different results, yes. Even in the same browser.

      • by AmiMoJo ( 196126 )

        Actually Bing is much more heavily censored than Google is. Try entering search terms in Chinese characters and you will find that they extended the censorship they use in China to the entire world. Google is blocked in China because they don't censor for the CCP, where as Bing is fully accessible.

        Bing nerfed it's image search too after being criticised for showing child pornography a few years ago. Now it's next to useless. By the way, the best image search is Yandex. As well as being less censored it does

        • by AmiMoJo ( 196126 )

          Oh sorry, I forgot that the snowflakes consider anything which suggests Google isn't pure evil and 1,000,000x worse than anyone else trolls them.

          Or maybe they binged these claims for evidence and came up with nothing, proving how good Bing's censorship actually is.

        • WOW so it's good to know you know where to search for kiddie porn.

          I am so bookmarking this comment. So glad Slashdot doesn't allow users to delete posts.

      • If you make a Microsoft Rewards account, you accumulate points for using Bing that can be converted (at an admittedly low rate) into Amazon credit. For someone like me who doesn't really care that Microsoft knows I'm searching for FF14 and WoW stuff, that's a great deal. And if you do care, you can just not take advantage of it and be no worse off than using Google.

        Granted, if you really want to protect your privacy, you need to use a privacy-respecting search engine, which is why I usually swap over to
    • by sunami88 ( 1074925 ) on Monday January 13, 2020 @05:27PM (#59617482)

      It's pretty clear that behind the scenes, DuckDuckGo is querying Bing's search engine and returning their results

      Correct, in a sense. From the first paragraph on Wikipedia [wikipedia.org]

      [...]generating those results from over 400 individual sources, including crowdsourced sites such as Wikipedia, and other search engines like Bing, Yahoo!, and Yandex.

      So it's not just Bing, but Bing is indeed one source.

  • ... the solution to an anti-trust suit born out of Google tying it's engine and browser to its OS, is to instead have other companies directly bid what they think the market value for those users are instead, thus handing Google their worth anyway?

    Interesting play, EU.

    • ... the solution to an anti-trust suit born out of Google tying it's engine and browser to its OS, is to instead have other companies directly bid what they think the market value for those users are instead, thus handing Google their worth anyway?

      If Android were an independent company without a search engine, isn't this exactly what it would do? Actually, not quite: It would do what Mozilla does, which is to silently default to the search engine that pays them the most, rather than offering each user a choice.

      • That is what google is doing now, from the article the search engines have to bid to get placed on the list, its not a public vote.

        • That is what google is doing now, from the article the search engines have to bid to get placed on the list, its not a public vote.

          My point exactly. It's what every other browser does.

  • So Microsoft won only in the UK, which is going out of the EU, which probably means this rule won't even apply.

    • Whilst we leave on 31st of January under the Withdrawal Act all current and new EU laws and regulations up to the end of the transition period on 31st Dec 2020 are written into UK law on that date. And then we can start to go through them, amend the amendable, bin the shite.
  • The “choice screen” is being introduced by Google following an antitrust ruling from the European Union last March. Google was fined a record $5 billion by EU regulators, who said the company had to stop “illegally tying” its search engine and browser to its mobile OS.

    The search engines shown to new users will vary for each EU country, with the selection decided based on a “fourth-price” auction system. Each provider tells Google how much it’s willing to pay the company every time a user selects their product as the default. The three highest bidders are then shown to users, with the chosen provider paying Google the amount offered by the fourth-highest bid. This process is repeated every four months.

    What a terrible ruling if competing search providers have to pay Google to appear as an option.

    • The “choice screen” is being introduced by Google following an antitrust ruling from the European Union last March. Google was fined a record $5 billion by EU regulators, who said the company had to stop “illegally tying” its search engine and browser to its mobile OS.

      The search engines shown to new users will vary for each EU country, with the selection decided based on a “fourth-price” auction system. Each provider tells Google how much it’s willing to pay the company every time a user selects their product as the default. The three highest bidders are then shown to users, with the chosen provider paying Google the amount offered by the fourth-highest bid. This process is repeated every four months.

      What a terrible ruling if competing search providers have to pay Google to appear as an option.

      I disagree. Note that I work for Google, but that has nothing to do with why I disagree. I disagree because the ruling was about bundling, and the requirement is that Google unbundle, i.e. behave the same way they would if Android/Chrome were made by a company that doesn't have a search engine.

      So, look at what Mozilla does: Mozilla solicits bids from search engine vendors and whoever pays them the most gets to be the default. Opera, etc. does the same. I'll bet Apple does the same with Safari, though

  • The summary is crap (Score:5, Informative)

    by alexo ( 9335 ) on Monday January 13, 2020 @05:17PM (#59617456) Journal

    The summary completely neglects to mention the most important aspect: this was an auction, and the search engines that "won" were the ones that offered the highest payment per user to Google. It has absolutely nothing to do with the quality or the popularity of the search engine.

    • the search engines that "won" were the ones that offered the highest payment per user to Google. It has absolutely nothing to do with the quality or the popularity of the search engine.

      Au contraire, it has EVERYTHING to do with the quality of the search engine. If you don't have money, you can't afford the bandwidth, storage, or processing power to do general internet searches. And if you don't have, can't process, or send out requested data then it doesn't really matter HOW GOOD your search algorithm is. If you DO have money, then you can always improve on it.

      Google's just the _Totally_ _Innocent_ _Victim_ here, honestly asking for advertisement dollars from fledgling indexers so the

  • Seriously, has Bing ever been relevant?
  • The choice is really between two search engines not four.

    Yahoo = Bing
    DDG = Bing
    Bing = Bing
    Google = Google

  • by Socguy ( 933973 ) on Monday January 13, 2020 @08:57PM (#59618060)
    Duck Duck Go doesn't track and it's not as good a Google. But it's good enough and it doesn't track so I use it!
  • So when will McDonalds be required to offer Burger King fries with their combo meals?

  • March 1 2020?

    I got this choice months and months ago, my phone wasn't new and already quite a while in use. Then one day when wanting to use search i got this popup asking me what my default search provider should be. I read about the ruling, so i figured they put it in place.

    I selected DDG.

In the long run, every program becomes rococco, and then rubble. -- Alan Perlis

Working...